New Zealand has a uniquely non-diversified higher education sector. In comparison to Australia, Singapore, Canada and other comparable jurisdictions, New Zealand has no private universities or polytechnics, no collegiate universities, and no statutory provision for independent specialised colleges accredited through universities. Given our small scale in the global higher education market, this is a significant comparative disadvantage for the innovative private sector as a whole. It means that the kind of distinctive higher education offerings that in Australia and elsewhere are provided by smaller specialised university colleges and private universities, are hindered here.
New Zealand public universities and polytechnics are, by design, incentivised to respond to larger and mainstream segments of both the teaching and research markets. For New Zealand to benchmark internationally, our higher education framework needs to adapt to recognise those non-public higher education providers that are already undertaking teaching and research of comparable quality and level to the universities or polytechnics, and providing unique research, innovation and training support to sectors of our economy. These private institutions are frequently offering provision that meets the needs of specialised markets – in fields as diverse as media technology, teacher education, and theology. They represent educational niches in which New Zealand could and should compete in the global market, but which operate at economies of scale below what our public institutions are incentivised to sustain.
This disadvantage also presents an opportunity. New categories of University Colleges and/or Universities of Specialisation, and Higher Research Institutes, could be allowed within the Education Act. This would recognise the private providers of higher education to be what they are, would create “category” name recognition internationally in contrast to the term PTE which has no relevance or resonance, and will enable these providers to grow market niches into robust institutions serving both international as well as domestic students looking for an alternative to public providers. The Act would need to change to allow a framework that is sufficiently fit for purpose for smaller and agile private players.